| TisBest | Charity on Top | Global Giving | The Good Card | Charity Choice | |
| Sponsoring Organization | TisBest Philanthropy | Charity on Top Foundation, Inc. | Global Giving | Network for Good | Special Kids Fund |
| Overall Ranking |  |
 |
 |
 |
|
| Cost and Fiscal Responsibility |  |
 |
|
|
 |
| Ease of Use |  |
|
|
|
|
| Product Quality | |
|
|
|
|
| Customization | |
|
|
 |
|
| Fees | $0 - $1.95 per Card 100% to Charity |
$0 - $1.95 per Card 96% to Charity |
$0 per Card 85% to Charity |
$2.50 per Card 100% to Charity |
$0 per Card 89% - 65% to Charity |
| Comments | The original charity gift card, introduced in 2007. Easy to use website. Custom images are free. No minimum quantity. Same or next day shipping. Institutional & corporate capacity. Experienced and helpful staff. | Upbeat website and email communications. Custom images are high quality and free. Greeting card choice. "Affiliate Fee Sharing" caution: 3.75% of all donations are transferred to a private corporation. | International giving portal also offering charity gift cards. Clean interface. Customization available. Excellent choice for international gifting. Long lead times and high fees. | Direct donation website, with charity gift card offering. No custom cards. No physical cards. | Confusing product selection. Customization only for bulk orders. Long lead times to ship. |
